Never good business people, these marginal contractors are caught in the spiral of the recent credit crisis and rising fuel prices. Looking for quick cash they find easy pickings by preying on homeowners. The incident below from Shannon and Mark Muhaw of Saluda, S. C. is too typical:
"My wife and I found Jeff Linette on Servicemagic.com and also saw his phone book ad. We called and set up an appointment to discuss our patio project. On 3/13/08 he gave us a quote and we decided to go ahead and sign a contract, which included a check for $3,000 that was cashed the same day. He wanted it made out to him, claiming there was an issue with his business account. He said he would be done in three weeks. When we didnt hear from him after a week we started calling. His first time here on the job was 3/27 for three hours when he pressure-washed our deck.
"We had him sign a new contract because I had a scheduling conflict that prevented him from being able to complete the job on the agreed date. Also, I wanted to go more into detail about what the job entailed.
"We didn't see him again till 4/11 when he spent three hours doing some cement patchwork. Again, we didn't see him again till 4/18 for another three hours. He said if we didn't give him another $2,000 he was done and walking off the job. He then lowered the amount to $1,000.
"I was at work at this time, speaking to him on my cell phone. My wife went outside to talk with Jeff. I heard them arguing and, because I knew she was home alone, I got alarmed and called the sheriff. We didn't file a complaint, however, as we tried to be nice and work it out. We felt trapped and settled on a $500 check which of course was cashed. It was for him to buy supplies to complete our project.
"We haven't seen him since. When he claimed his truck was stolen we even offered to pick him up to get him to complete our project. He will not return our phone calls. He always has a reason for not doing the work: his wallet got stolen, his phone got ran over, his phone got stolen. Yet when we call him from another phone number he miraculously answers."
The Muhaws did report this contractor to ServiceMagic.com who appears to have removed him from their service.
It's simple: Good contractors are on time and on budget. Bad contractors have an excuse for everything and often demand more and more money while doing just enough work to fool you into thinking that if you throw even more money their way you'll finally get your project complete. They size you up, figure you're good for it. You have two SUVs and a boat in the back. You can pay more, and too many often do. So what if a $5,000 deck costs $10,000? You got the deck, didn't you?
But challenge them and you will find they are the masters of hard-luck stories. Its amazing how imaginative these scoundrels can get as they play on your emotions. Their scam is designed to put you off and buy time, if for no other reason than they hope you get so fed up that you give up.
They thrive on excuses. They have an encyclopedic collection of them memorized, though they rarely need more than a dozen for every day scam work. Did you hear the one about the contractor who claimed to the homeowner midway through a kitchen renovation that he had cancer and was going into the hospital for emergency surgery? The homeowner later that week came across him on the golf course looking tan and fit.
These excuses serve a purpose. They frustrate you, make you anxious to get your project complete and your life back to normal. Our advice to you: don't buy into them. The first excuse leads to another and another. Its human nature to buy into the first excuse. You want to empathize, understand. But business is business and contracts are written for a reason: services and materials offered - payment rendered. Switch roles and ask yourself: "If I gave a contractor a hard luck story and didn't pay, would he be OK with that?" Fat chance.
So whenever you encounter the following excuses from a contractor consider them big, huge, fluorescent red flags:
-Asks you to get the required permits.
-Won't sign a contract, or does sign a contract but does not give you a copy.
-Starts demanding more money beyond anything agreed to.
-Insists you write checks to him personally, a family member, or anyone instead of in the name of the business you contracted with.
-Offers up a barrage of excuses for needing more money or more time.
-Doesn't return your calls.
-Uses lesser materials than what you agreed to.
-Shows up less frequently and works fewer hours as the project progresses.
-Subcontractors or members of his work crew complain about not getting paid.

