Mary Jenkins had a knock at the door on a Saturday afternoon. A respectable-looking man with a clipboard introduced himself as a tree doctor hired by the city. He was in her neighborhood to inform residents that numerous oak trees in the area were afflicted with Oak Wilt, a fungus-related disease. He went on to say that this fungus was infectious and could quickly spread to other oaks.
This news concerned Mary. Her home had been been in her family for generations and her grandfather planted the Red Oak in the front yard many years ago. That tree provided shade for her family for years. The thought that it was infected dismayed her.
The man said he had already taken a look at the tree before he came to the door and hated to deliver the bad news, but her tree was indeed infected with the fungus. He said the city had instructed that any tree infected with Oak Wilt must be cut down immediately to contain the fungus and prevent an epidemic. Mary was shocked by the news, but sadly agreed to have her tree uprooted. What else could she do? The city required it. A crew came the following morning and cut down her Red Oak, hauled it away, and handed Mary a bill for the testing of the tree and the removal: $600. She paid with cash without a second thought.
Mary's neighbor visited a few days later to ask her about the oak. She knew how important the tree was to Mary and wondered why it had been removed. Mary retold the sad story and asked her neighbor if the oak in her backyard was also infected. Her neighbor said no tree doctor or city employee ever came to her home. At this, Mary became worried. She first tried calling the number on the bill she received from the crew that removed the tree, but the phone number had been disconnected. Then she called the city, who informed her that they had no information about Oak Wilt in the area, had not hired a tree doctor and did not order any trees removed.
Mary was devastated. She'd been had. Her historic tree, perfectly healthy, was now gone forever because she did not question the word of a respectable-looking man who claimed to be sent by the city. To add insult to injury, the crew that removed the tree damaged her sod when removing the stump and broke her gutter with falling branches. Mary had to hire a landscaper and roofer to fix the problems. All in all, the scam ended up costing Mary in excess of $1500.
To avoid this type of scam, take the following tips into consideration:
1. Call in a tree specialist and get a professional, independent "second" opinion.
2. Check with neighbors to see if they are having tree problems as well.
3. If someone comes to your door claiming to be sent by local government, call them to verify.
4. Never pay in cash.
5. Never allow someone to come do work on your home when you arent there to supervise.

